The selects came back this morning as a voice memo: "we love the one where the chef is laughing, the two terrace shots, and that close-up of the plates, you know the one." Somewhere in the 600-photo gallery you delivered, four photos are hiding, and it is now your job to guess which ones.
What client favorites and notes replace
Client favorites and notes move the selects round out of your inbox and onto the photos themselves. Without them, feedback arrives in three broken formats:
- The filename list. "We want DSC_0481, DSC_0512 and DSC_0567." It breaks the moment anyone renames or re-saves a file.
- The screenshot roll. Cropped phone screenshots of your own photos, texted back at a fraction of the resolution.
- The description. "The one where everyone is laughing." Now you are the search engine.
A heart replaces all three with a mark on the photo, and a note pins "use this for the cover" exactly where it belongs.
The free ways to collect client favorites
Google Photos albums and Dropbox file comments collect reactions for free, and both suit small rounds.
- Google Photos shared albums. People can like and comment, and Google shows each person's profile photo or initial beside their reactions. Per Google's shared album help, "If you turn commenting off, people won't be able to like your photos." Google describes likes in the activity view and on the Updates page, not a filtered view of only the liked photos.
- Dropbox file comments. Dropbox's help center says "anyone who has access to a Dropbox file can leave a comment and view other comments, unless commenting is turned off." On an image you can drag a box around an area or comment on an exact point.
Neither Google Drive nor Dropbox keeps a shared favorites list, so a 40-photo selects round scatters across files.
For small hand-picked sets, sharing specific photos with clients covers the free routes in depth.
How proofing galleries handle client selects
Proofing galleries such as ShootProof and Pic-Time built the favorites round for shoot-by-shoot delivery, and they connect it to Lightroom.
- ShootProof. Favorites are listed per gallery visitor, in a Favorites column beside each client's email address, per ShootProof's favorites guide. With Favorites Notification, a client clicks Send Favorites, can add a note, and you get a dashboard notification plus an email. A Linked Contact can also apply labels you define.
- Pic-Time. The Workflow tab shows each user's favorites list, per Pic-Time's help center. Pic-Time 2.0 selection requests let clients "select, review, and discuss the images directly in the gallery in a live collaborative workspace."
- Pixieset and CloudSpot. Also proofing galleries; check their current pages for how favorites work.
Pic-Time's Advanced plan also adds AI photo search inside a gallery. The limit is scope: that search stays inside one delivered gallery, while an archive client needs to search across shoots.
Client favorites and notes on a searchable library link
For an archive, the shortlist has to sit on a searchable library, because the client's first problem is finding the photo, not marking it.
Tagrly's AI pass reads every photo in your Google Drive or Dropbox, or photos you upload, and writes a focal subject, supporting tags and a line of alt text, the method called focal-subject tagging. The scan runs unattended in the background, and the same tags power Tagrly's AI photo search. In Tagrly's own testing on a 5,000-photo set, focal-subject tagging surfaced the correct top match in roughly 9 of 10 searches.
A share link is a boundary drawn over that catalog, and Tagrly has two kinds:
- Collection link. A hand-picked set with hearts, a "picked" count and a Download picks button. No notes and no search box.
- Library link. Your library, optionally narrowed to collections, a pinned search or a minimum quality. Clients get a search box, hearts, a Picks button that filters to everything hearted on the link, and notes inside the photo viewer, plus a With notes filter once anyone leaves one. Left un-narrowed, it shows your whole library minus hidden photos, so narrow it per client; building a searchable client gallery walks through the setup.
Notes exist only on library links. Each is one line, capped at 280 characters, visible to everyone on the link, with no threads or replies. Authors can delete their own notes and you can delete any.
A note is labeled with the visitor's email if an email gate captured one, otherwise "Anonymous". The gate is self-reported: Tagrly checks the address looks real but sends no code.
Clients need no account to heart or note. Hearts are a Pro and Business control on Tagrly's plans, as are the password and email gate covered in the password protected gallery guide. Expiry, downloads on or off and the link's on/off switch come with every plan.

Warning. Hearts are share-wide: when anyone on the link hearts a photo, everyone on that link sees it as picked, and anyone can remove a heart for everyone. Agree up front who on the client's side has the final say.
Tip. Tagrly's free tier reads your first 100 photos, no credit card. Build a library link on your own photos to see the search box and notes before a client does; hearts come with Pro and Business.
Getting the shortlist back on your side
Each tool returns the shortlist in a different shape, so choose by what your next step needs.
- ShootProof. Copy a visitor's favorite filenames and paste them into Lightroom's Library text filter (Filename, Contains) to pull the selects. Spaces in filenames can break the match.
- Pic-Time. Download a user's favorites list, send it, or download it as a .csv. The Lightroom plugin can sync favorites into a Selections folder.
- Tagrly. Each link has an activity page listing the hearted photos (thumbnail, file name, the visitor's email when captured, when), every note in one table, and a log of views, hearts, downloads, notes and searches. Download picks zips everything hearted on the link when downloads are on.
Note. Tagrly sends no email or alert when a client hearts or notes, so check the link's activity page. Names in the zip and on that page are Tagrly's AI-written descriptive file names, not your camera file names, so there is no filename list to paste into Lightroom.
Whichever tool you pick, test the round trip first: heart three photos yourself, then confirm you can retrieve exactly those three.

Which photo gallery with client favorites fits you
Pick by where the shortlist has to end up: in Lightroom, with a client team, or in a small album.
| Option | Favorites | Notes | One list or per person | How you get it back |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google Photos album | Likes, off if commenting is off | Comments | Each like shows the person's photo or initial | Activity view, Updates page |
| Dropbox file comments | No shared list | Comments on a file, area or point | Visible to anyone with file access | File by file |
| ShootProof | Yes | Optional note with Send Favorites | Per visitor email | Email and dashboard alert, filename paste |
| Pic-Time | Yes | Discussion in selection requests | Per user; selection requests are shared | List, .csv, Lightroom plugin |
| Tagrly collection link | Hearts, Pro and Business | No | One shared list | Activity page, Download picks |
| Tagrly library link | Hearts, Pro and Business | One line, 280 characters | One shared list | Activity page, Download picks |
- Retouching rounds into Lightroom, or print sales. Pick a proofing gallery like ShootProof or Pic-Time. Filename paste and Lightroom sync are their home turf.
- A client-side team choosing from an archive. Pick a Tagrly library link: one shared Picks list, notes on the photo and a search box across shoots. Pics.io is another Drive-based catalog worth checking.
- A dozen finals, one client. Pick a Google Photos shared album with commenting on, so likes stay on too.
- Feedback on one hero image. Pick Dropbox file comments pinned to an exact point.
A photo gallery with client favorites and notes comes down to where the shortlist lives: under each visitor's email, in a shared selection request, or on a library link a whole client team searches. For one shoot headed into Lightroom, proofing galleries have it solved. For an archive, a photo has to be findable before it can be hearted, and our guide to finding any photo in your library covers that first step.
Frequently asked questions
Can clients mark favorites in a free Google Photos or Google Drive gallery?
In Google Photos, partly. A shared album lets people like photos and leave comments, and Google shows each person's account profile photo or initial beside their likes and comments, with sharing activity such as comments listed on the Updates page. Google's help page adds that if you turn commenting off, people won't be able to like your photos. Its help pages describe likes in the activity view and on the Updates page; they do not describe a filtered view of only the liked photos. Google Drive and Dropbox have no shared favorites list. Dropbox does let anyone with access to a file comment on it, including on an area or an exact point of an image, which suits feedback on one hero shot more than a full selects round.
Do clients need an account to leave favorites and notes?
It depends on the tool, so check before you send the link. Google Photos shows each person's account profile photo or initial beside their likes and comments. ShootProof lists favorites beside each visitor's email address, and Pic-Time keeps a favorites list for each user. In Tagrly, clients need no account to heart or note on a share link. A note is labeled with the visitor's email if the link's email gate captured one, otherwise Anonymous. The email gate is a Pro and Business control, and it is self-reported: Tagrly checks that the address looks real but sends no code to prove the visitor owns it.
How do I get the client's favorites into my editing workflow?
Proofing galleries are built for this step. In ShootProof, you copy a visitor's favorite filenames and paste them into Lightroom's Library text filter, set to Filename and Contains; spaces in filenames can break it. A client who clicks Send Favorites also triggers a dashboard notification and an email to you. Pic-Time lets you download or send each user's favorites list, or download it as a .csv, and its Lightroom plugin can sync favorites into a Selections folder. Tagrly works differently: each link's activity page lists the hearted photos and every note, and Download picks zips the hearted files when downloads are on. Those files carry Tagrly's AI-written descriptive names, so there is no camera filename list for Lightroom. No alert arrives either; check the activity page.
Can several people on the client's side share one favorites list?
In some tools. ShootProof lists favorites per gallery visitor, beside each client's email address, so three stakeholders mean three lists to merge. Pic-Time keeps a favorites list per user, but its selection requests let clients select, review and discuss images in a live collaborative workspace inside the gallery. Tagrly treats the link as the unit: when anyone on a share link hearts a photo, everyone on that link sees it as picked, and a library link's Picks button filters to all of them. Un-hearting is share-wide too, so anyone on the link can remove a heart for everyone. Before a client team starts, agree who has the final say.
Which Tagrly plans include client favorites?
Hearts, Tagrly's client favorites, are a Pro and Business control, along with the optional password and email gate. Every plan, free included, gets an expiry date, downloads on or off and an on/off switch for each link. Notes live on library links, the kind with a client search box, and they appear inside the photo viewer; a With notes filter shows up once anyone has left one. Collection links, the hand-picked kind, carry hearts, a picked count and a Download picks button, but no notes and no search box. Current plan prices are on the pricing page, so check there rather than relying on a figure copied into a blog post.
What is the difference between gallery notes and a full proofing workflow?
A gallery note is a short comment pinned to one photo: use this for the cover, crop tighter, not this one. In Tagrly a note is one line capped at 280 characters, visible to everyone on the library link, with no threads and no replies; authors can delete their own and the gallery owner can delete any. A proofing workflow is bigger. ShootProof pairs favorites with a Send Favorites note and labels you define, and Pic-Time's selection requests add a live space to select, review and discuss images. If your job includes retouching rounds into Lightroom or print sales, pick a proofing gallery. If a client team is choosing from an archive, notes on a library link cover it.
Try Tagrly on your own photo library
Connect your Google Drive or Dropbox folder and Tagrly will tag every photo in bulk. Search by what is actually in the image, share specific shots with clients, and never lose a photo again.
- Free for your first 100 photos
- Read-only access, revoke anytime
- No credit card